After a shock elimination from the Gold Cup qualifiers, Haiti calls up 7 new and young players from abroad to face Japan in a friendly on 10 October. The new faces are Jean Ambrose, Jems Geffrard, Bryan Alceus, Zachary Herivaux, Renald Metelus, Jimmy Sannon, and Richelor Sprangers. What do we know about those players and do they all deserve to join the national team? We look at each player background and performance at club level to determine whether a player receives the call on merit or not. Because all 7 players are under 25, we do not pretend that a player we deem undeserving of the call-up is unqualified for future selection. We understand that some players do improve the quality of their game as they become older.
Bryan Alceus - Technically, Alceus is not a new face since he has already represented Haiti in a friendly game versus Columbia in 2016. However, his contribution was so insignificant in the game that everyone agreed he was not ready for the national team. Is he ready now? The short answer is NO. For the past 3 years, Bryan Alceus has been bouncing between the 4th and the 5th divisions in France which is largely an amateur environment. Bryan Alceus is by no means the most talented attacking midfielder who can lead the team even with the assumption the FHF really does not want to make the most obvious and logical choice of using Charles Herold Junior. Although playing an offensive position, Bryan is very often buried in the center-field and as a result of his lack of attacking instinct, he has yet to score a single goal in his career as a footballer.
Other players with stronger claims to the midfield position include 23 year old Benchy Estama and 20 year old Roberto Louima. Those two young players are home-baked and would have been given priority over Alceus in every other federation except the FHF where Foreign-born players are more valuable than the Haiti ones.
HAITI SPORTS SCORE: Thumb Down ↓
Jean Ambrose: This is a 6 ft. 3 in. tall 24 year old defender with a decent resume. Born in France like many others on the list, this player is a serious competitor in comparison to the like of Genevois, Jean Sony Alcenat, Ricardo Ade, and Jerome Mechack.
However, Ambrose does not come without a package. The France-born player did play at a high level in France and Bulgaria but he is currently without a club. The player is apparently being sued by his last Bulgarian club Lokomotiv for leaving without permission before the end of the 2017 season. Should we take this as a warning of poor discipline?
HAITI SPORTS SCORE: Thumb Up ↑
Jems Geffrard - The 23 year old Haitian-Canadian defender is probably the most qualified player of the group with CONCACAF football experience. He has represented FC Montreal 14 times between 2015 and 2016. Another reason why capping Geffrad is a smart move is because the player is also eligible to play for fellow CONCACAF rival Canada.
Jems Geffrard currently plays for second division Finnish club Ikenas IF since 2016.
HAITI SPORTS SCORE: Thumb Up ↑
Zachary Herivaux -Like Bryan Alceus whom he had met at the U-20 two years ago, Herivaux is well-known among Haitian football fans as the Haitian-Japanese player of NE Revolution since he represented Haiti at the 2015 U-20 CONCACAF Qualifying toournament. The defender is worthy of the call to the national team. He is a career-oriented young man who takes his football-playing profession seriously. We have watched him transitioned from an alumnus to a full-grown player at the Revolution, although currently on loan at San Antonio FC.
By capping Herivaux, Haiti secures the services of a potentially strong defender that either USA or Japan may one day regret since the player was also eligible to represent either one of those two other countries. The 21 year old player is a good call.
HAITI SPORTS SCORE: Thumb Up ↑
Renald Metelus - This 24 year old player of French third division club US Avranches is a decent player who could have received an invitation for tryouts from any CONCACAF national teams where players are selected based on merit. In other words, he is not unworthy of this call-up because far worse players have been selected by the FHF before. That being said, the absence of Ricardo Ade on the list makes Renald Metellus' presence very suspect.
HAITI SPORTS SCORE - Neutral →
Jimmy Sanon -He bears the historic last name that will probably get the attention of the foreign media every time they saw him with the national team and just like his predecessor he can nail a goalkeeper several yards away. Surprisingly, the talented player of the U-20 team was a late addition to the list! Like Geffrard, Sanon is really a big 'panzou' Haiti has given Canada and the North Americans will certainly realize their mistake the next time they face Haiti.
No other player on the list deserves to be capped more than Sanon. The Canadian-Haitian forward has several years of experience in CONCACAF football despite his young age.
HAITI SPORTS SCORE - Thumb Up ↑
Richelor Sprangers- This relatively tall 19 year old player born in Haiti but raised in the Netherlands is a welcoming addition to a team that clearly lacks world-class finishers. Richelor played well at the U-20 and we feel strongly that he does deserve the call-up based on merit only considering his age and potential to grow with the team.
However, just like in the case of Alceus, there were other locally-based players who shine brighter than Sprangers at the U-20 who have not been called up. It is this lack of consistency and fairness that rob players like Sprangers the satisfaction of knowing that they were called up because of their efforts and not their status of players from abroad.
I think collat doesn't care about midfield he only plays pingpong long passes from defenders to forwards it was that style collat was forced to reject because he could not win any games. Alceus or not the midfield will be non-existing.
5-0 japan and hopefully president bananne jovenel seizes the fhf and orders the club owners to elect a new president.
Yipe! The majority of the players he calls up are defenders. How do you win when all you do is waiting in the back for the ball then throw it back up front hoping that on a lucky day one of your forwards will get to the ball first and miraculously scores! Haiti rarely scored during Collat's first stint because we always had Kervens and Nazon in the front, nobody really in the midfield, and 6 or 7 guys in the back throwing the ball back to the front.
Collat's style is anti-football. It is a sitting duck posture that teams like USA, Mexico, Costa Rica will always welcome.
Remember that it was under a lot of pressure that Collat reluctantly agreed to relax his rigid defensive style to play a more fluid football. The first time he actually made use of the midfield and allowed the players to move the ball around instead of throwing it back was versus China and the result was obvious. Everybody could see an improvement. Under pressure, he took the team to the gold cup but reverted back to his old fashion. The consequence was that the team always played for a tie unless the opponents were unlucky enough not to score in which case we likely lost.
In nearly 3 years, Haiti only managed to score 4 goals versus non-CFU teams! We lost or tied all our games versus non-CFU teams except one against an experimental Honduras team.
Collat left the national team because of failures. I have no idea why we are having him back. I have little doubt Collat will again pack the back with 5 standing defenders with 2 additional defensive midfielders in front of them. Even the wingers he will make sure they are more defenders than attackers. Basically, we will have 8 or 9 defenders and 1 or 2 strikers.
@Nah, mwen pa panse nou ap pedi 5-0 devan Japon paske Japon se yon ekip ki rate anpil gol e mwen pa kwe yo ap jwenn anpil okazyon gol. Men, mwen pa kwe nou ap make okenn gol eksepte si yon boul chans tonbe nan pye yon atakan ayisyen devan kan Japon an. Nou pap fe anpil atak paske pa gen mitan teren pou kontwole boul la.
M panse 2-0 oubyen 3-0 posib avek anpil dominasyon. Jan ou di a, prepare pou ping-pong ak neg ki pral vini di w se fot abit la si nou pran 3-0 nan dada nou.
Even though I really would love to see a team like the one who defeated T&T and Surinam to earn the play-off against Nicaragua, I would say this in favor of Collat, his team was more competitive playing at the higher level and really never got blown away by any other teams who were supposes to be better on paper than us..Im referring to the like of US, Panama, Honduras and.. Jamaica in that previous GC.. and I bet you a Collat's team wouldn't have been blown away by a team like Nicaragua .. His style, although not very offensive or aggressive seem to keep the team in all games..Im picking Haiti to lose by no more than 2 goals..like a 1-0, 2-1, 3 -1, 2-0 lost..
@Tini, you play football to win and that is the huge problem with Collat who plays football not to get blown away. If you pack 5 defenders and 2 defensive midfielders in your own half of course other teams will find it hard to score but most will eventually score once or twice. Since you do not have the manpower to strike back, you are likely to lose!
Do you play for 'honorable losses' or 'ties'? That is what Collat does. We know it because we all witnessed it for three years.
As for losing to Nicaragua, the fault was not on the style of football we played but on who we have in the team. We all know what was coming the moment we saw the list of players selected for the Nica games.
With Collat, Haiti would have still be eliminated because he would have done the same thing leaving out the better players for the ones FHF preferred just like Josaphat did. The only difference is that Collat's team wouldn't have won in Port-au-Prince. The team would likely tied Nicaragua 0-0 or 1-1 then played to another tie in Managua. That is Collat.